MC #104256 — Quran 19-TET Verification & učenje Claim Defensibility

MC #104256 — Quran 19-TET Verification & učenje Claim Defensibility

Status: ready-for-review evidence package, 2026-06-24.
Live site: https://ucenje.alai.no
Evidence root: /Users/makinja/system/evidence/104256/

Summary

MC #104256 corrected claim-defensibility issues on učenje.alai.no and the Quran 19-TET paper/supporting evidence. The final live site now avoids unsupported wording around:

• Surah 74:1–29 cumulative letter claim previously framed as 380 = 20 × 19 / 19×20.
• Overbroad qira'at wording such as “all eight qira'at”.

The reproducible verification bundle confirms the load-bearing ALR Hafs/Warsh findings and documents limitations/overstatements clearly.

Key evidence paths

• Final closure summary: /Users/makinja/system/evidence/104256/FINAL-CLOSURE-SUMMARY.md
• Live browser verification: /Users/makinja/system/evidence/104256/LIVE-DEPLOY-VERIFICATION/ucenje-live-claim-fix-verify.json
• Live screenshots: /Users/makinja/system/evidence/104256/LIVE-DEPLOY-VERIFICATION/screenshots/
• Full verification bundle: /Users/makinja/system/evidence/104256/INDEPENDENT-VERIFICATION/
• Full run log: /Users/makinja/system/evidence/104256/INDEPENDENT-VERIFICATION/run-all-20260624-170829.log
• Manual Hebrew Torah log: /Users/makinja/system/evidence/104256/INDEPENDENT-VERIFICATION/hebrew-torah-20260624-171112.log
• Hebrew result file: /Users/makinja/system/evidence/104256/INDEPENDENT-VERIFICATION/controls/RESULTS-hebrew-torah.md
• Jahić review queue: /Users/makinja/system/evidence/104256/bosnian-sentences-for-jahic.md

Machine verification results

Reproducible bundle

Command:

cd /Users/makinja/system/evidence/104256/INDEPENDENT-VERIFICATION
bash data/fetch-external-corpora.sh
bash RUN-ALL.sh
python3 controls/hebrew-torah-alr.py

Results:

• RUN-ALL: PASS 11 / FAIL 0 / SKIP 1.
• RUN-ALL skip: Hebrew Torah is skipped by script design because it always requires Sefaria network calls.
• Manual Hebrew Torah: spread = 14, verdict POKLAPA; C(24,5) percentile = 66.2738%, verdict POKLAPA.

Live/browser verification

Script:

/Users/makinja/system/evidence/104256/LIVE-DEPLOY-VERIFICATION/ucenje-live-claim-fix-verify.js

Result JSON:

all_passed: true

Checked live pages:

• https://ucenje.alai.no/
• https://ucenje.alai.no/19-explorer/
• https://ucenje.alai.no/mladi.html
• https://ucenje.alai.no/content/math-aha-bs.md
• https://ucenje.alai.no/content/math-aha-en.md
• https://ucenje.alai.no/content/math-aha-no.md

Final browser result had:

• status 200 for all checked pages
• forbiddenHits = 0
• consoleErrors = 0
• failedRequests = 0

Forbidden live patterns checked absent:

• 380 =, 380 slova, 380 letters, 380 bokstaver
• 19×20, 20 × 19, 19 × 20
• svih osam ... qira, all eight ... qira, alle åtte ... qira

Deployment note

The standalone Cloudflare Pages project for the live domain is ucenje, not alai-web. The successful final deploy used a root-normalized artifact generated from public/ucenje, with /ucenje/ links rewritten to /, then deployed to project ucenje. This fixed previous browser MIME failures caused by requests to /ucenje/assets/... on the standalone domain.

Independent review notes

• A first Company Mesh attempt was BLOCKED because the responder could not access files/live data.
• External delegated Proveo task MC #104312 timed out in the pipeline and was not counted as PASS evidence.
• A bounded Company Mesh evidence-sufficiency review with embedded evidence excerpts returned PASS:
  • Thread: mesh-thr-f3f32632-b639-4dfc-a1a3-9e9501824541
  • Message: mesh-msg-ced6dbca-3ce1-4c46-b325-9795587a0c50

Known limitation / follow-up

New or modified Bosnian sentences are queued for Jahić linguistic review. This is tracked in the evidence file and should be treated as a language-quality follow-up, not a blocker for the machine-verification evidence.

Independent review marker — Gemini + Redžo

Gemini: APPROVE_WITH_NOTES — report saved at /Users/makinja/system/evidence/104256/GEMINI-REVIEW-REPORT.md. Gemini concludes the work is mature and intellectually honest when it preserves the evidence hierarchy: ALR/19 Hafs+Warsh as the reproducible core; audio as educational/experiential sonification; Lejletul-kadr/lunar observations as correlation/research signal, not theological proof.

Redžo/local MLX: APPROVE_WITH_NOTES — report saved at /Users/makinja/system/evidence/104256/REDZO-LOCAL-REVIEW.md. Redžo agrees the work should pass review because unsupported claims were retired and the model is now anchored in algorithmic reproducibility, with strict guards against overclaiming.

Website marker added: the public učenje homepage now states the same review outcome and guardrails: ALR/19 = reproducible core; audio = educational sonification; Lejletul-kadr/lunar layer = correlation/research signal, not theological proof.

• Live website marker deployed to https://ucenje.alai.no/ and verified by Playwright: /Users/makinja/system/evidence/104256/LIVE-DEPLOY-VERIFICATION/ucenje-review-marker-verify.json (all_passed: true).

Operational rule: future text must not promote audio or lunar observations into proof. If that happens, the review status no longer applies.